top_left top_right
bottom_left
Next Event: Unknown | Forum Rules | QGL Website | Event Registration
openFolder AusForums.com
iconwatfolderLineopenFolder LANs
iconwatfolderLineopenFolder QGL
iconwatfolderLineopenFolder QGL Forum
Author
Topic: New MP3 decoder prices
Swiss_Cheeseman
Posts: 561
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland
From Slashdot:

"The licensing terms of Thomson and the Fraunhofer Gesellschaft, who are the owners of the mp3 patents, have changed. Now not only mp3 encoders but also mp3 decoders require a license. This page lists the fees -- it's $0.75 per decoder. As a consequence, Red Hat has already removed all mp3 players from the Rawhide development version."

Everyone, move to OGG, and abandon MP3, OGG is better anyway.
system
--
orbitor
Posts: 2510
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
ogg is good. switch now.
Swiss_Cheeseman
Posts: 562
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland
http://www.mp3licensing.com/royalty/software.html

thats the page that lists the fees btw
Tael
Posts: 1801
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Like people won't just work around it by using the software they already have.
Pharcyde
Posts: 3102
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Does this mean that we will have to pay for winamp?
Tollaz0r!
Posts: 4559
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

ogg is good. switch now


Too late, soo much mp3.. so little ogg, what is ogg anyway?
Swiss_Cheeseman
Posts: 591
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland
http://www.vorbis.org

No, you wont have to pay for winamp, cos they are backed by a large organisation, they can afford the liscence. Not many other freeware developers can tho.
Shotty
Posts: 2493
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Actually, it was never the fact that you had to pay for the mp3 patent when creating a software decoder.

The license holders only chage money to those who sell a product using mp3 technology. For example , hardware decoders (portable mp3 players). And this has always been the case, ever since the beginning.

The only thing that has changed is that they took the words out of the web page about how software (free) decoders were free.
Frag
Posts: 704
Location: Queensland
ogg's better ne ways.
fpot
Posts: 6182
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland
uhhh, exactly?
DaFuGG
Posts: 400
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
yes but sadly the winamp ogg vorbis decoder plugins aren't anywhere NEAR as advanced in terms of options and quality as the bam decoder or whatever..

plus, "this friend has a lot of mp3s" and i.. err.. "he" doesn't want to f***ing convert them all to ogg unless he (a) has to or (b) has a really good program to do so


hmm

If i wrote a program to do massive batch conversions of mp3s to ogg vorbis would anyone use it? because the libraries are out there to do it..
Neldy
Posts: 29
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
go back to uni defugg d:
do some work

leave me and my mp3s alone, i dun wanna have to fscking convert them all the time i wanna wack them on my mp3 player (a physical one not a proggie)

SquarkyD
Posts: 3264
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
If i wrote a program to do massive batch conversions of mp3s to ogg vorbis would anyone use it? because the libraries are out there to do it..


yes
Shotty
Posts: 2498
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
If i wrote a program to do massive batch conversions of mp3s to ogg vorbis would anyone use it? because the libraries are out there to do it..
Ahhh.. no. That wouldn't make any sense now would it. Ogg is higher quality for less file size, but you are not going to get better quality from an mp3. More sound is not going to just appear out of no-where. In fact, on the ogg vorbis site it explicitly recommends not converting mp3 to ogg, because although the file size will be smaller, the quality will be slightly less. Ogg needs to be made from preferably the original source, or .wav

teen
Posts: 6103
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
how the hell do all these people suddenly know about ogg? it has never even been mentioned here before.
verticalseafoodtaco
Posts: 262
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
woah maen you mean to say the internet is more than just qgl.org?
teen
Posts: 6104
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
what other site do you go to?
system
--
Not a new post since your last visit.
New Post Since your last visit
Back To Forum
Advertise with Us | Privacy Policy | Contact Us
© Copyright 2001-2026 AusGamers Pty Ltd. ACN 093 772 242.
Hosted by Mammoth Networks - Australian VPS Hosting
Web development by Mammoth Media.