|
![]() |
|
| Author |
|
|||||||
|
taggs
Posts: 2996
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Posting this is probably a bad move, but oh well:
For Australia, this is not the worst downturn since the Great Depression of the 1930s - it is not as bad as the recession of 1991 or 1982, and is comparable with the downturn in 2000 [where we DIDN'T follow the US into recession]. In fact this is only a modest downturn by historical standards. How much of Australia's resilience is due to China and how much to domestic economic stimulus is debatable. The point is now that this stimulus needs to be unwound - the only question is whether it will be unwound by Reserve Bank governor Glenn Stevens or Prime Minister Kevin Rudd. emphasis in italics/square brackets is mine. The odds are shortening that we have just experienced another episode in Australia's unhappy history of policy over-reaction to perceived crises. Paul Keating's infamous "recession we had to have" in 1991 was caused by policy failure - interest rates were too high for too long at the end of the 1980s. And earlier, the stock market boom and bust of 1987 was due to the opposite - interest rates being too low. source: Guest, R 2009, 'Economic Recipe Far Too Hot', Courier Mail, 16 Sep, p. 30. (can't find a link so far) Ross Guest is a professor of economics @ Griffith. THE Reserve Bank has challenged Wayne Swan's account of the success of his economic stimulus measures, with several board members declaring that it is hard to know how much credit belongs to them and how much to its own cuts in interest rates and the economic resurgence of China. http://www.smh.com.au/national/reserve-questions-swans-stimulus-story-20090915-fpol.html The federal government has again rejected opposition calls to withdraw its stimulus, insisting the measures will remain until economic growth returns to pre-crisis levels. http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-world/stimulus-here-till-growth-recovers-swan-20090906-fcb2.html So without resorting to too much partisan bulls***, do you think the fiscal stimulus has gone too far? mods: can all stupid posts like pave's please be deleted? i don't want retards s***ting in my srs thread please :( |
|||||||
| #0 07:01pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
system
|
--
|
|||||||
| #0 |
|
|||||||
|
paveway
Posts: 10453
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
* N U K E D *
Reason: First nuke in this thread lol |
|||||||
#1 08:40am 16/09/09
|
|
|||||||
|
Denny
Posts: 3316
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I think it's a mixed bag and it's pretty hard to know how cause and effect will operate
If you were to say (as the govt) that the stimulus will be rolled back because it's no longer needed what you might well find is that business/consumer confidence was largely based on expectations of future govt support/spending and we'd have a related recession/downturn in 3 months time as business cuts back as well. I think the short term deficit is necessary and at the most the govt should (quietly) cut the longer term expenditure which hasn't already been initiated. In the medium term a gradual shift to a balanced budget is desirable and in the future a small surplus should become the goal. Note that theoretically I'm not adverse to deficit spending however this needs to be based on realistic assumptions re: GDP growth causing the spending to be neutral. I think Australia's long term outlook is a bit darker because China/India won't be consuming at a frenetic pace forever and largely it's the pace of consumption which has caused the unrealistic resource prices. |
|||||||
| #2 08:29am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Spook
Posts: 26220
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
yay stimulus
|
|||||||
| #3 08:33am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
mission
Posts: 5622
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I think Rudd should give out more ca$h.
|
|||||||
| #4 08:34am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
cainer
Posts: 1496
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Look at the one first world country that has been through this in recent history.
Japan. Depression, stimulus after stimulus after stimulus after stimulus, 0% interest rates and what ? their economy is full of banks that 'are too big to fail', the largest government debt in the world and their economy is still f***ed. The whole idea of booms and busts is to let the strong survive and the weak fall by the way side. It would've been like our government bailing out Ansett because they were 50% of the airline market. Would that have been the right thing to do ? |
|||||||
| #5 08:37am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
tequila
Posts: 3212
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
wow, what a beautifully unbiased position you've taken in the OP
my grand kids are going to be paying this stimulus back from them, I say - f*** YOU RUDDY DUDDY |
|||||||
| #6 08:44am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Denny
Posts: 3317
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
The whole idea of booms and busts is to let the strong survive and the weak fall by the way side. It would've been like our government bailing out Ansett because they were 50% of the airline market. Would that have been the right thing to do ? Except that Ansett isn't an integral part of the economy. Ansett isn't where everyone keeps their money. I think you've failed to appreciate just how dangerous a bank failure is. It's through banks that most economic growth is facilitated. That aside which bank-bailout are you complaining about in Australia? We haven't had any. the government (quite properly) has guaranteed deposits (which everyone assumed they were doing all along) but that's a very different thing to a "bail-out" |
|||||||
| #7 08:51am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Denny
Posts: 3318
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
my grand kids are going to be paying this stimulus back This is certainly true based on the following assumptions: 1. Australia fails to grow at a rate larger than our deficit, if we grow faster than the money borrowed it's a prudent investment 2. You presume that the spending is inherently wasteful. I'll concede some of it certainly will be. Single-student schools aside (as the anomoly) you did want to continue maintaining the nation's public schools right? So what better time to do it than when a) the State Govt's are broke/in the red and b) the Fed govt has the ability to borrow and c) you need to do something marginally productive to keep people employed. |
|||||||
| #8 08:55am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
taggs
Posts: 2999
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
wow, what a beautifully unbiased position you've taken in the OP yeah, it's not hard to work out my stance - but i'm interested in other people's opinions :) also, i don't really look at it from a liberal/labor perspective - policymakers in general f*** up most of the time. i have little confidence that a liberal solution to the GFC would have been much better. though i prefer the politician i think is a retard to the politician i know is a retard. cainer: good point, while the japanese economy has some pretty drastic differences to most free market western economies it is easy to draw some parallels between their lost decades and this crisis/response. |
|||||||
| #9 09:10am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
tequila
Posts: 3216
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
take *every cent* away from private schools and give it to public schools
if rich people want to send their kids to private schools, let them but for the *majority* of people who send their kids to public schools, give them all the money they need to run a public school properly sif we didn't mostly waste our rudbux s***, I can't even remember what I bought - it was probably something for my car |
|||||||
| #10 09:40am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Alt_F4
Posts: 1083
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Pretty much agree with the points your were drawing light on, taggs.
My main gripe with the whole issue (party politics aside) is that once Labor put the various legislation through the house of reps, the decision of whether to pass it through the Senate ultimately came down to the small group of independent senators. I realise that they were effectively voted in by the people of Australia, but it just seems absurd to me that the final decision about if the policies came into play was dependent on a few select individuals (Xenophon, Fielding, etc) who probably have a somewhat limited capacity to understand the full implications of the economic policies they voted for. I guess this is one of the failings of Westminster based Parliament systems. These stimulus packages were pushed out waaaaay too quickly, a little bit more time should have been spent planning & debating over the specifics instead of trying to run some kind of 'scare campaign' to get it rushed through Parliament as quickly as possible. |
|||||||
| #11 09:51am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
mission
Posts: 5624
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Weren't you on your high horse about giving it to the fire victims?
|
|||||||
| #12 09:54am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13501
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
i agree with cainer. assets need to be revalued, and weak companies need to be allowed to fold.
you can't have a boom without a bust. |
|||||||
| #13 10:05am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
CHUB
Posts: 5500
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
These stimulus packages were pushed out waaaaay too quicklyYep, that's why lazy bums like me got $1850 ($900 worker, $950 student) :D Sup loophole! |
|||||||
| #14 10:09am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
cainer
Posts: 1497
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Except that Ansett isn't an integral part of the economy. Ansett isn't where everyone keeps their money. I think you've failed to appreciate just how dangerous a bank failure is. It's through banks that most economic growth is facilitated. Why has it come to the point in this world that there are a handful of major banks in the world, australia has 'the big 4'. Of course its totally banking self interest to make themselves totally 100% integral in this world, its a survival mechanism but it only serves to benefit the banks at the end of the day. Lack of competition, state/worldwide protection because theyre too big to fail. What the governments should've done, if they had the balls, and weren't totally reliant on keeping the big banks on their side, is yes, bail them out, then split those f***en leeches on society up into multiple smaller banks. What we would have then is diminished risk across society, more choice, more competition. Thats the rationale for doing it to telstra isn't it ? But of course that won't happen.. It could also be suggested that the whole fractional reserve banking system should be totally wound back. If there were a fixed amount of money in the system we wouldn't have credit/asset bubbles, we wouldn't have inflation, we would have fiscally responsible governments and we'd probably have a sustainable world economy, not one which just uses everything it possibly can until its all gone |
|||||||
| #15 10:22am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Mr Hardware
Posts: 5553
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
teq it doesn't work like that. if you gave all the money to public schools you'd end up with the kids worse off than they already are, because private schools actually save the govt money. just like private health insurance saves the govt money rather than everyone leaning on the public health system, thats why there's the 30% rebate.
|
|||||||
| #16 10:27am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
TicMan
Posts: 5066
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
|
The cash splash was a severe waste of tax payers money. The stimulus packages should have all been put on infrastructure (roads, schools, health, etc) as the long term benefits are significantly better than me using my free money to have a holiday to Tas with wifey.
|
|||||||
| #17 10:31am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Pinky
Posts: 2439
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
|
teq, your post doesn't make any sense. You already have rich people paying 47% tax and you want to discriminate them further by not allowing any of that money that was taxed off them go into funding for their kids schooling? Not to mention rich people buy expensive cars (stamp duty) and properties (land taxes, more stamp duty) and more taxes everywhere they bloody well spend money. Please, never enter politics at any level. TicMan stated exactly my point of view. |
|||||||
| #18 10:55am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 4502
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
wow, what a beautifully unbiased position you've taken in the OP Heh, all the crazy s*** that's happened in the last few yrs is why I'm not having kids. vasectomy is your friend. |
|||||||
| #19 11:05am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
mission
Posts: 5625
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
You're not having kids because we had a recession?
|
|||||||
| #20 11:08am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Mr Hardware
Posts: 5554
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
better than me using my free money to have a holiday to Tas with wifey.You and your mrs had an interstate holiday too on krudd's dollars? Hi 5! |
|||||||
| #21 11:09am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 4503
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
No because I dont have any confidence in things getting better. Rudd's cash splash debt bomb only cements this.
|
|||||||
| #22 11:10am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
TicMan
Posts: 5068
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
|
You and your mrs had an interstate holiday too on krudd's dollars? Hi 5! Was a great holiday too, glad I didn't have to pay for it with my money and used Kevvys money instead that my great-grand kids will pay off with interest! OH SNAPPLES! |
|||||||
| #23 11:14am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
mission
Posts: 5626
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
That would have to be the wierdest reason I've ever heard for not having kids :/
|
|||||||
| #24 11:17am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Spook
Posts: 26223
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
im only sad that i didnt have more kids so they could have seen our great leadering giving mummy and daddy all that cash
|
|||||||
| #25 11:19am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Mr Hardware
Posts: 5555
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
slaps doesn't realise that he's supposed to have kids so they can pay off krudd's debt for him.
|
|||||||
| #26 11:20am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13502
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
i just find the whole concept of money for nothing offensive. in a normal economic bargain, one person promises to do something or sell something to another person for an agreed value.
in the stimulus case, people have to do nothing to receive money. how is that in any sense of the word good for the nation's productivity? secondly, banks are parasites, they thrive off econmic activity because they are charging a % of it as interest, whether it be through credit card fees, eftpos machine charges, ATM charges, interest on loans, buying commonwealth bonds. of course they support the bailouts and stimulus because they are the one financing the government, the stimulus contractors and the consumers. after they bought a truckload of toxic assets (noT so many in aus), they ran out of capital to leverage up their lending, so there is one kind of lending which has ZERO capital backing requirement... guess which kind of lending that is under the Basel II banking convention? GOVERNMENT DEBT last edited by infi at 11:31:40 16/Sep/09 |
|||||||
| #27 11:31am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 4505
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
That would have to be the wierdest reason I've ever heard for not having kids :/ Granted, letting Rudd's stupidity influence my decision is a bit silly but I stand by my decision not to bring kids into the world when the future is not looking to bright. Seems a fairly rational way to look at it if you ask me. |
|||||||
| #28 11:36am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
mission
Posts: 5627
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I'm intrigued, why isn't it looking bright?
We just went, or are still going through, a 'tough time'. We still have running water, sewage, cars, TV, internet. We aren't a starving community in Africa. While it's your decision not to have kids, your reasoning just seams to be a really weak cover for other issues. |
|||||||
| #29 11:42am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13503
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
There's plenty of other breeders out there to make up for him.
|
|||||||
| #30 11:46am 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Mr Hardware
Posts: 5557
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
yeah unfortunately most of the other breeders are braindead and don't think about having a kid or not, it just 'happens'
|
|||||||
| #31 12:02pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
FaceMan
Posts: 1670
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
September 30
Shock and Awe |
|||||||
| #32 12:20pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
paveway
Posts: 10455
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
what happens when september 30 goes by and nothing out of the ordinary happens?
will you leave qgl or something? |
|||||||
| #33 12:26pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13507
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
do you mean the invasion of iran, Faceman?
|
|||||||
| #34 12:36pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Jim
Posts: 10292
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
illusions infi
a trick is something a whore does for money |
|||||||
| #35 01:52pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Jim
Posts: 10293
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
or candy!
|
|||||||
| #36 01:53pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Mr Hardware
Posts: 5558
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
oh, i always thought that was sex
|
|||||||
| #37 01:53pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Denny
Posts: 3319
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I've got to laugh. We're pretty much, if not the, only developed economy which has avoided a recession and the idiots in the cheap seats turn around and get angry about the measures the govt took to help avoid recession.
You can't win can you. As I said, govt debt and inflation are legitimate concerns at any other time but now is not the time to prioritise them. |
|||||||
| #38 03:27pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
fpot
Posts: 16394
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland
|
infi: how do you feel about chicks for free?
|
|||||||
| #39 03:37pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13511
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
that i have no problem with, especially for a needy soul such as yourself.
|
|||||||
| #40 03:44pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
fpot
Posts: 16395
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland
|
See now if I were you I'd make a mum joke right about here.
|
|||||||
| #41 03:44pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Jim
Posts: 10294
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
measures the govt took to help avoid recessionlol |
|||||||
| #42 03:46pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
mission
Posts: 5632
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
He used up his daily mum joke allowance in the petrol thread.
It was awesome. |
|||||||
| #43 03:46pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Obes
Posts: 7864
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
If we had guns we could shoot the government!
|
|||||||
| #44 03:50pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
fpot
Posts: 16396
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland
|
Yeah. Shoot them right in the stimulus package!@!@!@
|
|||||||
| #45 03:53pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Spook
Posts: 26228
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
measures the govt took to help avoid recession no lol |
|||||||
| #46 04:42pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13512
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
WE STARED INTO THE ABYSS
|
|||||||
| #47 04:54pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
deadlyf
Posts: 470
Location: Queensland
|
I try not to look directly at it.
|
|||||||
| #48 05:03pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
taggs
Posts: 3000
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
hey obes i think you can use that 'joke' at least 4 or 5 more times. seriously, it's still funny.
Spoiler: no it's not oh s***, i wasted my 3000th post on obes-tard :( last edited by taggs at 17:42:11 16/Sep/09 |
|||||||
| #49 05:42pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
taggs
Posts: 3001
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I've got to laugh. We're pretty much, if not the, only developed economy which has avoided a recession and the idiots in the cheap seats turn around and get angry about the measures the govt took to help avoid recession. i suppose everyone is questioning the price paid to avoid the technical definition of a recession. that is making the (somewhat quesionable) assumption that the stimulus packages had a significant effect in that regard. i posted a graph in the previous thread showing that the 2nd round of stimulus payments had a pretty weak effect on consumer spending, the 1st round had a somewhat stronger effect. so i guess people are also questioning how much effect the government stimulus package had, compared to exogenous factors such as demand for exports from china. government debt and inflation should always be concerns, no matter what point in the cycle we are at. the situation in australia was nothing like the climate in UK/USA, so to say that we should spend 'whatever it takes' and then worry about the debt later is completely unethical, imo. |
|||||||
| #50 05:41pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Boxhead
Posts: 12079
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
'Economic nationalism has no place in the Eu'
heh, thats a pretty ominous statement coming out Europe over the last few days.. |
|||||||
| #51 05:56pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Jim
Posts: 10297
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
spook :D
|
|||||||
| #52 06:04pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Alt_F4
Posts: 1084
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I've got to laugh. We're pretty much, if not the, only developed economy which has avoided a recession and the idiots in the cheap seats turn around and get angry about the measures the govt took to help avoid recession. With that statement you have naïvely assumed that it is all thanks to the Government that we avoided 'recession'. While I don't deny that the stimulus would have had some effect, there are many other factors at play. Also, you have to question if they could have achieved the same result for a lesser cost to taxpayers. It is not correct to try and compare Australia directly to other developed countries. Australia is one of the smallest countries in the OECD, and as such, operates quite differently in some respects at the macroeconomic level. Consider that: -We were extremely well positioned leading into the GFC with no debt and strong surpluses in preceding years -Our banking sector was one of the strongest in the world. As a whole, they had limited direct exposure to subprime. The public maintained faith in the system, thus we had no major bank runs like UK with Northern Rock. -Australia was very lucky to be such a small country that has a floating currency, the ability to borrow in it's own currency, and current account deficits. These three factors basically meant the brunt of the damage would only be a temporary decline in our currency while things were at their worst (ie the fall in the USD from 98c to 60c) -Finally, Australia is somewhat independent from other countries. The United States Economy is somewhat tied to China, for example. All the European countries are linked. This obviously makes it a lot easier for the nation to rebuild, and external factors will cause less of a shock to our economy. So, I hope this helps you begin to realise that there are an enormous amount of factors at play, and it would be foolish to not question the Government. last edited by Alt_F4 at 18:10:40 16/Sep/09 |
|||||||
| #53 06:10pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13515
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
that's far too logical, it was swan the economical muthaf***en genius.
|
|||||||
| #54 06:32pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
FaceMan
Posts: 1676
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
wtf ? Its not over yet.
|
|||||||
| #55 08:28pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
taggs
Posts: 3006
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
lets turn this into a calling out faceman on his bulls*** thread.
September 30 so faceman, what is going to happen on september 30? i will be bumping this thread on sep 30 so i hope your crystal ball isn't broken! |
|||||||
| #56 09:23pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
FaceMan
Posts: 1677
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Look forward to talking to you then.
|
|||||||
| #57 10:09pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Jim
Posts: 10303
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
lol 'talking'
for you that just means more smoke and mirrors and never actually answering anything |
|||||||
| #58 10:21pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
FaceMan
Posts: 1679
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Thanks for caring.
|
|||||||
| #59 11:42pm 16/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Spook
Posts: 26231
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
from todays paper
THE Federal Government's stimulus package has protected jobs from the fallout of the global financial crisis, the Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development (OECD) says. The OECD believes 150,000 to 200,000 Australian jobs would have been shed in 2009. |
|||||||
| #60 06:10am 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Saint
Cainer
Posts: 2424
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
^^ So it's official, the Labor government's stimulus packages did their job. Thanks Kev!
|
|||||||
| #61 06:38am 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Strange Rash
Posts: 1078
Location:
|
But I don't trust kev to look after something that doesn't need fixing... or his foney smile for that matter.
|
|||||||
| #62 06:54am 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
taggs
Posts: 3007
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
spooky old bean, noone is disputing that a government throwing money around willy nilly isn't going to protect jobs. what we are questioning is the price paid to keep those jobs:
ECONOMISTS say Kevin Rudd has traded off long-term value for money for short-term economic gain with his stimulus package, amid revelations his government has spent about $160,000 for each job saved. http://m.theaustralian.com.au/Economics/pg/0/fi8079.htm they could have given every worker made redundant an $80,000 cash payment for half the money :P edit: above comment is a little tongue-in-cheek, obviously not that simplistic. needs to be weighed up against long-term costs of u/e that would have occurred without the stimulus. my thoughts are, though, that the stimulus had a far less significant effect compared to our terms of trade effect. last edited by taggs at 09:42:15 17/Sep/09 |
|||||||
| #63 09:42am 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Jim
Posts: 10307
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
it was already official once you made your recent thread on it saint!
|
|||||||
| #64 07:42am 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Spook
Posts: 26234
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
interesting point taggs
ill give you that big kev isnt as efficient as he could have been, but hes still out there trying and isnt that really what matters? (well, trying and me getting free money) |
|||||||
| #65 07:55am 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
`ViPER`
Posts: 1519
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
ECONOMISTS say Kevin Rudd has traded off long-term value for money for short-term economic gain with his stimulus package, amid revelations his government has spent about $160,000 for each job saved. Economists are always full of s*** everyone knows that. Its a stupid statement to say stimulus spent/jobs saved = $ value for each job. |
|||||||
| #66 09:04am 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13517
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
i have a report somewhere from Michael Knox, ABN Amro, which rates the wastage on the stimulus program at oveer 30%.
|
|||||||
| #67 09:22am 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
taggs
Posts: 3012
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Economists are always full of s*** everyone knows that. Its a stupid statement to say stimulus spent/jobs saved = $ value for each job. so you obviously had serious objections to rudd/swan claiming that the budget would protect 200,000 jobs back in May? http://www.smh.com.au/business/billions-blown-to-bail-out-workers-20090511-b0lb.html how do you propose the effectiveness of the stimulus package should be measured? presumably you have a more appropriate metric we could use, o wise one? |
|||||||
| #68 09:37am 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Tollaz0r!
Posts: 9888
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
We should rate it in beans.
|
|||||||
| #69 09:46am 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Pinky
Posts: 2448
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
|
taggs, it was the Govt's responsibility to demonstrate that the stimulus was the correct move before it was implemented. A drastic move like that hasn't been tested before. They should have therefore stated that yes, it's somewhat of a gamble but we believe this this this. Not the way they did which was it WILL do this, it WILL do this. And then they should have set up their own method for assessing the success. A method which should have been tabled in parliament and agreed on as the official way to measure the impact. There are massive gaps in all of this. Certainly the true widespread impact of any large scale stimulus is impossible to measure. The crappy, amateurish way that the stimulus was brought in and implemented is what I don't approve of. It's just the usual, sloppy day to day work of the Labor Party. |
|||||||
| #70 09:58am 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
taggs
Posts: 3014
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
A drastic move like that hasn't been tested before. They should have therefore stated that yes, it's somewhat of a gamble but we believe this this this. Not the way they did which was it WILL do this, it WILL do this. of course it has. there have been several stimulus packages in the US over the last 5-10 years, and several more in Japan over the last 2 decades that i can think of off the top of my head. there have been studies done in regards to the effectiveness of those packages in terms of marginal propensities to consume (MPC) and other metrics. in the previous thread i posted such a study on the australian packages from an economist from ANU, but i felt it wasn't overly robust as it was based on survey data. i was just calling out viper on his comment because i bet he's happy to listen to economists if their views coincide with his own! cognitive dissonance is a bitch. edit: spellinglols last edited by taggs at 10:20:42 17/Sep/09 |
|||||||
| #71 10:20am 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13518
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
referring back to cainer's statement. japan has had the s*** stimulated out of it for nigh on 20 years. it now has debt to GDP of close to 100% and is still in the doldrums.
stimulus does not provide any long term benefits to an economy, it's just to make the pollies look good and whack a bunch of "building the nation" signs up around all the schools for next election day. |
|||||||
| #72 10:35am 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
`ViPER`
Posts: 1520
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
i was just calling out viper on his comment because i bet he's happy to listen to economists if their views coincide with his own! cognitive dissonance is a bitch. Huh, yeah probably. I was more just saying that with such a huge thing like the econimic stimulus, its a bit silly to divide one figure by another and say thats the result, its way more complex than that, way to complex for a normal person like me to figure out. A 100 page report on the effect of the stimulus isnt as good for a headline or quote as "Rudds job's cost $160k each" I cant say 100% that the stimulus was completely a good thing and that they spent the exact right amount of money. I think some stimulus was needed, makes sense to me that the government steps in when there is a decline by the private industry. Maybe some if the stimulus money wasnt spent in the best way, who knows, spending money on schools seems like a good idea, the insulation rebate and solar hot water rebate are a good idea. |
|||||||
| #73 10:47am 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
FaceMan
Posts: 1683
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
The IMF just called...
They want to enslave your country. |
|||||||
| #74 12:39pm 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
thermite
Posts: 2654
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
The IMF just called... The people from mission impossible? |
|||||||
| #75 12:41pm 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13526
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I can feel a Job appearance coming!
|
|||||||
| #76 12:54pm 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Alt_F4
Posts: 1090
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
i have a report somewhere from Michael Knox, ABN Amro, which rates the wastage on the stimulus program at oveer 30%. **RBS Morgans |
|||||||
| #77 12:55pm 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
dazedandconfused
Posts: 1
Location: Sydney, New South Wales
|
The stimulus package will be BAD for Australia in the long run. This is because there is now 42billion (times that by roughly 10, so 420billion due to the fractional reserve banking principle ALL banks engage in) injected into the economy that was created out of NOTHING by the Reserve Bank. This means that the government is now 42billion in debt to the bank, and the interest payments on this are filled by INCREASING INCOME TAX. So, expect that lovely $900 stimulus package to go straight into income tax hikes in the next few years. The Federal Reserve in America engineered the crash, to plunge the world as a whole into even MORE debt than they are already in. There is not one single government in the western world that is not in debt to their PRIVATE central bank, who also happens to be their currency provider. Neat system. |
|||||||
| #78 01:01pm 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
`ViPER`
Posts: 1522
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
The Federal Reserve in America engineered the crash, to plunge the world as a whole into even MORE debt than they are already in. Have u meet faceman, you two would get along. |
|||||||
| #79 01:03pm 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
mission
Posts: 5636
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Is that you Faceman?
Edit: beaten by that much |
|||||||
| #80 01:04pm 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Jim
Posts: 10322
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
The IMF just called... http://brianseay.files.wordpress.com/2008/09/arrested_development_gob_magic.jpg |
|||||||
| #81 01:08pm 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Denny
Posts: 3320
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
||||||||
| #82 01:35pm 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Spook
Posts: 26240
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
i have a report somewhere from Michael Knox, ABN Amro, which rates the wastage on the stimulus program at oveer 30%. we just changed over all their mailing work |
|||||||
| #83 01:36pm 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13527
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Oh yeah! For mine, every time Faceman makes a magical unreferenced statement he's getting the Job treatment.
|
|||||||
| #84 04:37pm 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
TicMan
Posts: 5077
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
|
i have a report somewhere from Michael Knox, ABN Amro, which rates the wastage on the stimulus program at oveer 30%. 100% HERE! |
|||||||
| #85 04:41pm 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
`ViPER`
Posts: 1523
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
i have a report somewhere that says malcolm turnball eats babys
|
|||||||
| #86 04:57pm 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
ara
Posts: 2811
Location: Sydney, New South Wales
|
|
|||||||
| #87 05:15pm 17/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13534
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I finally managed to track down that newsletter from economist Michael Knox, 4 Feb 2009:
To assess the benefit of this package, we will purely look at the economic modelling provided in the document. Page 3 of the document tells us that ‘the economic impact of the Plan is that GDP growth is expected to be around half a percent higher than 2008/09 and around three quarter percent to one percent higher in 2009-10 than it would have been without the Plan’. How much has the government spent to achieve these results? On page 42 in Table 4.3, we are told that the total policy decisions impact on the fiscal balance in 2008/09 is $19.643 billion. In 2009/10 it is $19.747 billion. Taken in the context of the other information in the table, this appears to be slightly less than 1.7% of GDP in 2008/09 and slightly less than 1.7% of GDP in 2009/10. This means that in 2008/09 we are spending 1.7% of GDP in stimulus to get an increase in GDP of 0.5%. This means we are spending $1.00 in stimulus to get only 30c in GDP. This is an amazingly low multiplier of 0.3. This is very low by international comparison it is even low by the standards of the Treasury’s own commentary on page 15. The situation improves slightly in 2009/10. In that year we are spending 1.7% of GDP stimulus to get an increase in GDP of 0.75% to 1%. This means we are spending $1.00 in stimulus to get between 45c and 60c in GDP. This is a low multiplier of 0.45 to 0.6. We conclude that by emphasising social infrastructure over economic infrastructure, the ‘bang for the buck’ achieved is so soft it might better be described as a ‘dull thud’. last edited by infi at 16:47:32 18/Sep/09 |
|||||||
| #88 04:47pm 18/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
FaceMan
Posts: 1689
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Was talking to a friend yesterday who is no dummy with money.
He'd invested $270 000 with City Pacific and the company locked up just after the Financial Crisis hit. Its likely he will get nothing back yet the Owner and his Wife has managed to build a $32 million property portfolio. It hasn't wiped him out but theres a lot of other people that have lost everything. Its prolly going to be popping up in the media very soon. Sounds similar to that Storm Financial. Stick with Gold. |
|||||||
| #89 04:53pm 18/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
FaceMan
Posts: 1690
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Whats with the ActiveX thing that wants to run ?
|
|||||||
| #90 04:54pm 18/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
taggs
Posts: 3020
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
faceman, anyone who is friends with you is by default a dummy in every possible sense of the word.
|
|||||||
| #91 05:00pm 18/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
taggs
Posts: 3110
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
September 30 hi faceman, just letting you know i haven't forgot about this! what's going to happen? i'm very excited!! regards, taggs |
|||||||
| #92 02:56pm 30/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Pinky
Posts: 2620
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
|
taggs, I love you In the only way a man can love another man (EDIT: Turned mean post into nice post) |
|||||||
| #93 03:29pm 30/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Opec
Posts: 5887
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
taggs, clearly you don't understand time differences, it's still 29th/Sep in the US. He still got at least 24 hours before the prediction will come to fruition.
|
|||||||
| #94 02:59pm 30/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
taggs
Posts: 3111
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
haha, what have i done!? i just freaked out thinking i'd noobed the date up or something.
yep, i'm willing to give him until 30/09 has finished elsewhere in the world. hence why i'm so excited to see what's going to happen! |
|||||||
| #95 03:00pm 30/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13687
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
it is kind of exciting and nerve wracking at the same time. this build up in the index is highly reminiscent of 2007, and we all know what happened then. |
|||||||
| #96 03:05pm 30/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
FaceMan
Posts: 1770
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Ive still got tonight before i get hung.
Did any of you check that Baltic Shipping index thing i posted in the other thread ? I tell you what its going to happen very soon. http://investmenttools.com/futures/bdi_baltic_dry_index.htm last edited by FaceMan at 16:28:25 30/Sep/09 |
|||||||
| #97 04:28pm 30/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Hogfather
Posts: 3692
Location: Cairns, Queensland
|
Was talking to a friend yesterday who is no dummy with money. Your friend is either very rich (multi-millionaire) or he is a dummy with money for dropping that much cash into a single entity. Ask any dickwit in the street and they'll tell you to diversify. |
|||||||
| #98 04:30pm 30/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13694
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
what do all those charts tell you, faceman? make a logical statement. |
|||||||
| #99 04:30pm 30/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
FaceMan
Posts: 1771
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Like i said it didnt clean him out.
Lets wait and see later tonight. |
|||||||
| #100 04:33pm 30/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Jim
Posts: 10434
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
but still... where'd the lighter fluid come from?
|
|||||||
| #101 04:35pm 30/09/09 |
|
|||||||
|
fpot
Posts: 16446
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland
|
SHOCK AND AWE
|
|||||||
| #102 01:04pm 01/10/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Opec
Posts: 5892
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Is the world still going? I can't tell
|
|||||||
| #103 01:25pm 01/10/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Spook
Posts: 26404
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
ive taken all my money out of the bank and stocked up on baked beans and blankets, just in case;
|
|||||||
| #104 01:30pm 01/10/09 |
|
|||||||
|
taggs
Posts: 3115
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
from aldi?
|
|||||||
| #105 01:32pm 01/10/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Jim
Posts: 10441
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
it's still only 8pm on the other side of the date line
|
|||||||
| #106 01:32pm 01/10/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Opec
Posts: 5894
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
The world seems like it's still going so, it makes me wonder if he's going by some ancient Mayan or Aztec calendar or something? Maybe he's meant 30/9/2010 ?
|
|||||||
| #107 01:34pm 01/10/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Pinky
Posts: 2646
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
|
You've done the right thing, Spook. Leaving for the bank now. Will stop by Forty Winks to pick up a mattress to stash my loot in. |
|||||||
| #108 01:34pm 01/10/09 |
|
|||||||
|
FaceMan
Posts: 1777
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
You got to wait for the Lag...
haha dropped a little last night can i get a an extension ? |
|||||||
| #109 01:35pm 01/10/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Alt_F4
Posts: 1126
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
S&P500 down 2.58% last night. Sizeable but not quite shock and awe.
|
|||||||
| #110 08:26am 02/10/09 |
|
|||||||
|
paveway
Posts: 10586
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
you should make more predictions like this faceman, they are good for a laugh
|
|||||||
| #111 08:27am 02/10/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Alt_F4
Posts: 1127
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
And if he makes enough, some will probably turn out true!
|
|||||||
| #112 08:34am 02/10/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Spook
Posts: 26416
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
is it safe to come out yet?
|
|||||||
| #113 08:41am 02/10/09 |
|
|||||||
|
infi
Posts: 13706
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
there is a pretty big correction, the usd has made a major u-turn meaning people are chasing cash and bonds over equities. the latest bond issues in both the UK and US have had strong support.
my long usd position got closed out overnight because i lucikly has a stop sell in place. it fell over half a cent in hours. so now i am shorting it as the momentum builds. when the herd changes sentiment, you would be a fool to try and fight it. something is brewing... |
|||||||
| #114 10:11am 02/10/09 |
|
|||||||
|
sLaps_Forehead
Posts: 4514
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
|
|||||||
| #115 10:43am 02/10/09 |
|
|||||||
|
system
|
--
|
|||||||
| #115 |
|
|||||||
|
| ||||||||