|
![]() |
|
| Author |
|
|||||||
|
Mass
Posts: 500
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I know this was discussed a while ago but don't want to revive old threads. Anyone running these adapters......do they work well? I am thinking of hooking my xbox360 over it and just curious for any problems.
|
|||||||
| #0 12:18pm 13/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
system
|
--
|
|||||||
| #0 |
|
|||||||
|
boba
Cainer
Posts: 3204
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I had 3 adaptors until one started smoking and stopped working. Apart from that they do the job but can be slow depending how old your house/wiring is.
|
|||||||
| #1 12:26pm 13/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
TicMan
Posts: 3704
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
|
My father in law runs these at his place and doesn't get great results. Connects at around 800kbits which I suppose comes down to cabling more than anything.
Why not look into one of the ethernet to wireless adapters instead? I moved house and had to hook up my old WGE111 again and it runs a dream connected to my Xbox. Admittedly I don't use it (Xbox) for gaming but it's more than able to stream media across without any problems. |
|||||||
| #2 01:27pm 13/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
Mr Hardware
Posts: 3724
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
depending on your house they can be far better or far worse than wireless. For example, a big solid brick house with excellent wiring is going to probably favour EoP, however an older open plan house with paper thin walls and weird old wiring will favour 802.11a/b/g. Personally, i'd only go with EoP when wireless just cannot work well, even with big boost/gain/antennas etc, mainly due to the high-ish price of EoP adapters.
|
|||||||
| #3 02:47pm 13/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
Mass
Posts: 503
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Thanks for the feedback guys. I'm not paying for them so price doesn't worry me. Its purely because I am trying to stream to the xbox. The router is up stairs at front of the house, xbox is downstairs at rear of house. The house is about 3yrs old and is a 2 story rendered brick so hopefully the wiring should be good.
|
|||||||
| #4 03:20pm 13/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
greazy
Posts: 833
Location: South Korea
|
how much does it cost to set up 4 computers using this setup?
|
|||||||
| #5 05:06pm 13/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
stinky
Posts: 2804
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
have you got a wireless network already? might be better off trying wireless first. I agree that you're much better off with wireless, unless it doesn't work well for you.
for signal issues, build one of these - http://www.freeantennas.com/projects/template2/default.htm http://www.freeantennas.com/projects/template/ |
|||||||
| #6 05:12pm 13/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
Nathan
Posts: 2972
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I previously used 2 of the "200mbit" ones (I've since moved and had ethernet installed in my walls)
My experience was I could get up to 20-30mbit transmission over decent distance; at "point blank" (same socket) it got to 50mbit per second. For me it was noticably better real-world performance than wireless; in particular it didnt suffer from dropouts like my wireless did/does. If cost is not a factor, I definately recommend it over wifi. |
|||||||
| #7 05:20pm 13/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
Fn
Posts: 5243
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Woo all bow before the almighty Nathan :D
Thanks for the info on the faster ones I've been trying to get real world infoshizzal Choice |
|||||||
| #8 09:51pm 13/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
Nathan
Posts: 2980
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Fn; it was Mass who said cost wasn't a barrier for him. I was just pointing out that EOP is more expensive than wireless.
Ethernet through wall is cheaper than both (cost me $120 installed by licensed data cabler) and far better if you can do that |
|||||||
| #9 09:09am 15/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
Jim
Posts: 8696
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
that's pretty awesome, and definitely cheaper than I've seen those EoP thingies for
|
|||||||
| #10 09:25am 15/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
3x0dus
Posts: 1100
Location: Townsville, Queensland
|
i have used the netcomm 85mbps models to run from one house to a shed ~ 130meters.
Speed was closer to around 1.5~ Mb/s, About the equiv of speed when my wireless in the house says a nice 54mbs connection. (which would not work reliably over the 130meters). In the situation i had, running an ethernet was not an option, and wireless may work fine, or it may not, and required much more cost $$$. the 200mbit models seem to me of a gimmick than the 85mbit ones. For what it does and the price i paid for a pair <$120 , was still much cheaper than a properly paired wireless connection. |
|||||||
| #11 09:50am 15/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
greazy
Posts: 863
Location: South Korea
|
Ethernet through wall is cheaper than both (cost me $120 installed by licensed data cabler) and far better if you can do thatthis would be awesome for my house. Who did you get to do it? |
|||||||
| #12 12:50am 17/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
Ross
Posts: 1636
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I used them as well, only got slightly better results than wireless. They where some netgear ones. The bit that annoyed me was that to sync properly it had to be early in the power chain or directly into the wall socket. Because the are wide its hard to plug things in next to them. I did also get a small performance boost from switching to thor boards and putting them on the isolated port. Still not as good as straight into the wall though. I also noticed that if you do daisy chain a bit that the more stuff turned on, on the downline the worse the performance. Just run cable through the walls
|
|||||||
| #13 01:10am 17/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
Nathan
Posts: 2982
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
this would be awesome for my house. Who did you get to do it? I'm in Canberra, but it was this guy http://www.customsurveillance.com.au/ I agree with Ross about the giant size of them being lame. Its unfortunate you cant rent them from somewhere, because it seems like the results really do vary widely depending on each house's wiring etc |
|||||||
| #14 02:11pm 17/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
greazy
Posts: 865
Location: South Korea
|
Just wondering how many outlets did you get installed and was your house a one-story or two-story house?
|
|||||||
| #15 03:18pm 17/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
Ross
Posts: 1641
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
for the wiring? got a cat 6 outlet in every room, 2 story house. Used the guys at electronicliving.com.au based in Briz, was very reasonably priced but they where doing a lot of other jobs for me as well. I imagine they would be pretty pricey to get in and do just that. Any electrician can do it and if you take a look over your home and contents insurance you might be able to do it yourself..
14 outlets all together and god knows how many metres of cable, if I had to guess about 200 - 300m (I don't have 14 rooms, 6 where for the media rack) came to about 3.5k i think from memory and that included some power points an exhaust fan and some other repair jobs. |
|||||||
| #16 03:37pm 17/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
Ross
Posts: 1642
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
If any body wants to borrow/buy my adaptors for free/$20 they are welcome to them.
|
|||||||
| #17 03:40pm 17/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
E.T.
Posts: 1531
Location: Queensland
|
Hi Mass. I got a couple of these for the exact same thing. The performance was wrose than my wifi. I ended up getting my money back and runnning network cable around my house to do it right. No I can stream to my hearts content :)
|
|||||||
| #18 04:04pm 17/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
Nathan
Posts: 2987
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
My guy charged a flat $120 per connection (ie, 2 end points) regardless of cable length , which I just have running from PC room to TV room.
|
|||||||
| #19 04:15pm 17/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
Ross
Posts: 1647
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
that's pretty dang good nats, so its better to get electricians than av guys :)
|
|||||||
| #20 06:27pm 17/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
greazy
Posts: 869
Location: South Korea
|
Wow I thought it would be cheaper. I got quoted $110 + GST for one point.
|
|||||||
| #21 09:36pm 17/10/08 |
|
|||||||
|
system
|
--
|
|||||||
| #21 |
|
|||||||
|
| ||||||||