|
![]() |
|
| Author |
|
|||||||
|
3dee
Posts: 4328
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
After having done a lot of graphic design and web development lately, its become apparent I need a better monitor. Current one is an LG 22" which is a mediocre 18-bit TN panel and I need something that will display full 24-bit natively and also be better for doing CMYK stuff. and a few more pixels wouldnt go astray too :D
I don't want to spend too much (for the kind of monitor I want) so anyone have any recommendations for 24" monitors for semi-frequent graphic design etc? |
|||||||
| #0 08:51am 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
system
|
--
|
|||||||
| #0 |
|
|||||||
|
Reverend Evil™
Posts: 16744
Location: Wynnum, Queensland
|
Atomic Magazine
Check out that link dudette. They did a nice test of some 24" monitors that might help ya out. f***, that link is to an older 22" review. They did a 24" one in the August edition which was pretty cool. Sorry. last edited by Reverend Evil™ at 09:09:14 23/Aug/09 |
|||||||
| #1 09:09am 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Eds
Posts: 9021
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
||||||||
| #2 09:17am 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
3dee
Posts: 4329
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Looks pretty good Eds, though I can't find any results on Google. Is it absolutely brand spanking new model?
|
|||||||
| #3 09:44am 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Jim
Posts: 10157
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
yeh it is
you can still get the 2408WFP's though too, I just ordered another 4 on friday |
|||||||
| #4 10:23am 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
HerbalLizard
Posts: 3136
Location: Queenstown, New Zealand
|
I was looking for a couple of non tn pannel monitors myself, ended up picking up some old 20" cina displays for 150 each. You could always just get a second hand ezio off someone. Saw a couple of lacie 24"'s on greys about 6 weeks ago which where pretty cheap for what they are
|
|||||||
| #5 11:36am 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Crizane Tribal
Posts: 2635
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Definitely go Dell IMO. The graphics guys at my work use them and they're awesome. Plus their service is good too.
|
|||||||
| #6 01:20pm 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
kos
Posts: 1387
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
|
Dell for sure, I still have my 2407 going strong and it's still better than any other new 24" lcd I've seen since. |
|||||||
| #7 01:45pm 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
ctd
Posts: 7525
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I've had my a dell 24" for over 3 years. The screen stopped working just before the 3 year warranty ran out and it only took 3 days to replace...
Took a few months to convince them that I actually ordered the monitor from dell though. They are like "whats the service tag?" This monitor doesn't have a service tag sigh. After many phone calls and frustration I got one of India's finest on the other end of the line and he finally found my order details after asking for my mobile phone number. Anyway good monitor and turn around time but if you lose your proof of purchase receipt make sure you give them every detail you can think of if they don't believe you. |
|||||||
| #8 02:00pm 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Mantorok
Posts: 3759
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
..but if you lose your proof of purchase receipt make sure you give them every detail you can think of if they don't believe you.Isn't that how pretty much every retail business operates though? |
|||||||
| #9 03:46pm 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
ctd
Posts: 7526
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Dell keeps all orders on their side but for some reason when I gave them my name they didn't have a record until I gave them my mobile phone number? Not the only thing I have ordered from dell either.
|
|||||||
| #10 03:49pm 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
greazy
Posts: 1543
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
You have a really common name?
|
|||||||
| #11 03:56pm 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
simul
Posts: 551
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I've got a 2407, its good, great monitor for the price, but the colours really don't get close to my cinema display. If your not too worried about colours, then yeah Dell is great, but yeah, I'd say cinema display or higher if your doing pro GD stuff (this being said the only reason I notice is cause I have them set up as dual montiors).
|
|||||||
| #12 04:43pm 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Eds
Posts: 9022
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I have a 2408 myself at the moment, considering the 2410 or an apple display for photo editing soon.
Undecided yet. |
|||||||
| #13 04:55pm 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Reverend
Posts: 1395
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland
|
yer i have the dell 2707wfp best monitor i have ever used or seen. ( though its now 2 years old ) |
|||||||
| #14 05:27pm 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Eds
Posts: 9023
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
The biggest thing I dont like about my 2408 is that the anti glare coating seems to give a shimmering effect, expecially bad on white but in photos and what not if you look closely.
I am hoping the 2410 has fixed that. I would love a 30" display but the jump is soo much money. |
|||||||
| #15 05:45pm 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Mass
Posts: 611
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
HP LP2475w is supposed to be the best 24" on the market at the moment (except for their 30bit tri-colour LED backlight model - but its nearly $5K). Beats Dell hands down in all the reviews.
http://h10010.www1.hp.com/wwpc/au/en/sm/WF05a/382087-382087-64283-3884471-3884471-3648442.html |
|||||||
| #16 07:10pm 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Jim
Posts: 10160
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
supposed to be EH
|
|||||||
| #17 07:58pm 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
3dee
Posts: 4331
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Yeah I think a Dell is the go. That U2401 looks quite nice (110% colour gamut, high contrast and most of all true 24-bit panel). The main thing is that I want something under a grand. The Applle Cinema Displays are very expensive (for what I want).
|
|||||||
| #18 09:03pm 23/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Nathan
Posts: 3229
Location: Canberra, Australian Capital Territory
|
Dell, end of thread. |
|||||||
| #19 11:20am 24/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
3dee
Posts: 4338
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Now to round up 900 bucks....
|
|||||||
| #20 11:51am 24/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
demon
Posts: 4594
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
pfft. i got a dell 24" at work.. dunno what model... but it's crap. contrast ratio is weak... very hard to tell close pastel colours apart. it's only just over a year old n the colours seem very faded. i just got a new lg l246whx a few months ago & it's colour & contrast is so much better than the dell. coz i run them both side by side it's really obvious that the dell has a more faded look about it.
it probably is a s***ty model dell tho... cant see a model # on it anywhere. |
|||||||
| #21 11:56am 24/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
mission
Posts: 5488
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
I'm not sold on the whole Dell thing either.
I'm far from any expert but I use a Dell 20" wide (only a few months old) and a 17" Acer (I suspect a few years old) and the Acer has the better picture. The Dell isn't bad but when it's beside the Acer it's colours etc aren't as good. This may not really apply to their more expensive models though, I suspect mine is a more budget office model. |
|||||||
| #22 11:59am 24/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Eds
Posts: 9028
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Dell uses several different panels between their models and sizes also. So if your 20" is crap (which I would definatly believe if its the cheap one) it doesnt meant the 24" is s*** (I have one of these as well, so I dont believe it :D)
|
|||||||
| #23 12:05pm 24/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
Jim
Posts: 10163
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
yeh dell have 2-3 versions in each or most of their sizes, I know there's at least 2 in 24", one cheap and doesn't look so great and the 2408WFP which does look good imo. the cheapy is about $300-$400 and the ultrasharp/2408WFP is about $635-$800 depending on whether they have a special running or not. the rrp in the website is often even dearer
|
|||||||
| #24 01:20pm 24/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
3dee
Posts: 4339
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
The difference between TN panels and decent IPS panels is quite significant so I'd say yours would consumer TN panel models if they don't look that great. My LG 22" is a TN and its looks pretty poor really. It has a shimmer effect when display moving or changing gradients between frames, its strange. The other thing is that it does dithering to make is s***ty 18-bit 256K colour panel look "like" 24-bit, but it doesn't come close...
|
|||||||
| #25 01:42pm 24/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
3dee
Posts: 4341
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
|
Oh man there's a 27" IPS panel that is around the same quality as the U2410 for $1050. DOES WANT
|
|||||||
| #26 02:48pm 24/08/09 |
|
|||||||
|
system
|
--
|
|||||||
| #26 |
|
|||||||
|
| ||||||||