top_left top_right
bottom_left
Next Event: Unknown | Forum Rules | QGL Website | Event Registration
openFolder AusForums.com
iconwatfolderLineopenFolder LANs
iconwatfolderLineopenFolder QGL
iconwatfolderLineopenFolder QGL Forum
Author
Topic: Another Plasma vs LCD question
Kat
Posts: 9947
Location:
Okay, we have a problem (oh I love how spending lots of money on wants is a problem :p).

We pretty much do half tv watching half movie watching. The tv will be mounted (ah HA mount) so no kids will touch it. It will be in an area that can be light or dark. Plus a whole lot of other mumbo jumbo elvis is cluey about

So pretty much we are stuck. Which way do we go? Because it sounds like half of our requirements point to lcd and half to plasma :(
system
--
mongie
Posts: 5386
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
The tv will be mounted (ah HA mount) so no kids will touch it. It will be in an area that can be light or dark. Plus a whole lot of other mumbo jumbo elvis is cluey about


No idea what any of this means.

Buy a plasma. You'll thank me later.
Spook
Posts: 22001
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
hooking a pc up to tv?
lcd:

actualyl screw it, just buy an lcd anyway, no one bothers with plasmas anymore

nice sony or samsung and you'll be laughing;
Kat
Posts: 9948
Location:
Aren't they being phased out or something due to power? Or did I just get a few snippets off buzz words and create my own uneducated story?

Yes it will be hooked up to a computer - myth
Spook
Posts: 22002
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
pretty much;

Midda
Posts: 2352
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
They're both good, so just go with whatever one you can afford to get in a bigger size imo.
mongie
Posts: 5387
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Plasma's use power differently to LCD's.

LCDs have a large constant draw from their backlight. The LCD panel is made up of pixels which are each made up of 3xSubpixels.

To create white, the panel lets all light through.
To create black, the panel tries to block out as much of the backlight as possible.

Power draw is always constant (give or take a little).


Plasmas don't have a backlight. They're made up of individual cells made of 3x subcells. R+G+B.

To create white, all of the cells are completely on, which is the max power draw for the plasma.

To create black, all of the cells are completely off, which uses no power (give or take).

So, while LCD's always use about 60% of the power used by a plasma, a Plasma's power draw fluctuates based on whats on the screen.

-

I just stumbled upon this gem... Its as if it was written for Spook.

e-bay Australia buyers guide - Plasma v LCD

Some highlights...

Picture Quality

Plasma

Plasma panels offer a wider range of colours than LCD panels latest models offer up 68.6 billion colours. Plasmas provide wider viewing angles (over 170 degrees) with consistent colour and reproduce deeper blacks since only the required parts of an image are lit, resulting in more dynamic and natural images.

LCD

Conventional LCD panels suffer from narrow viewing angles, where colour is often washed out when pictures are viewed from the sides. Since LCD televisions need to block out the bright backlight for any dark areas of an image, they typically do not reproduce blacks quite as well as plasma displays.

--
Natural Motion

Plasma

Plasma displays use phosphors (just like a conventional CRT TV) to provide rapid, natural moving images. This makes plasma displays superior for watching movies or sports action.

LCD

While LCD TVs can provide high-resolution images, most cannot provide the natural motion of plasma TVs. Conventional LCD TVs tend to suffer from slow display speeds (response times), often causing ‘dragging’ or ‘ghosting’ of fast moving images, resulting in poor picture quality.

--
Power Consumption

Plasma

Plasma displays only emit light where necessary, consuming less power on average when displaying moving images than their peak power ratings indicate. This results in plasma displays being more economical for television viewing, offering lower yearly power consumption in large screen TVs.

LCD

Although some LCDs quote lower peak power ratings than similar sized plasma displays, they constantly keep a bright backlight on regardless of the image being displayed. LCD power consumption is always at around the same level, consuming more power on average than high performance plasmas when viewing moving images.


last edited by mongie at 16:32:09 09/Jul/08
Midda
Posts: 2353
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Holy f***, who cares? That was a really convoluted way to basically say "yes, Plasmas use significantly more power overall". With the latest LCD and plasmas, just about all of those things you mentioned are non-issues. The only big difference now are the black levels, and even that's not really as big of an issue as it used to be.

As I said above, I reckon just go for whichever one you can get biggest in your price range. If you're looking at new generation plasmas and LCDs, you'll be happy with either one.

last edited by Midda at 16:39:24 09/Jul/08
`ViPER`
Posts: 431
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
I still say plasma, it just always looks better than lcd tome, sure lcd looks good for playing xbox/ps3 and cartoony movies, but on normal tv and movies, they just look pixelated.

Then again a super expensive Sony bravia LCD probably looks great for most things, but its just so much more than a similar size plasma.

52" sony bravias are over $5000 when you can get a 50" panasonic plasma for $3000, yes its 2 inches smaller, but 2 grand more, you could get another 42" plasma for that for the bedroom/other room, I know what i'd prefer.
Midda
Posts: 2354
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Or you could just buy a Samsung, since they make the panels for Sony anyway. For $3000 though, would a 50" Panasonic plasma even be 1080p?
Spook
Posts: 22003
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
any lcd review that says there is motion blur/ghosting/dragging is several years old, or they are looking at s*** panels;

ffs, even my s***ty cheap lcd in teh bedroom doesnt have an issue with high speed stuff, like the footy

viewing angles also are pretty much a furphy

unless of course you want to sit at some rediculous angle to watch tv:
ara
Posts: 2195
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

I love how the term "conventional" is used in mongie's quote.

Not current technology, or latest.

Guide created: 01/10/06 (updated 09/07/08)

It would be interesting to find out what if anything has been updated in there since October 06.

My LCD doesn't have any of the "problems" that are described in mongie's article and I bought it over 18 months ago. Like most things, you get what you pay for.
`ViPER`
Posts: 432
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
For $3000 though, would a 50" Panasonic plasma even be 1080p?


Yep, Panasonic Plasma that can be found for about 3k is a 1920x1080 panal.
orbitor
Posts: 7646
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Just get the biggest HD panel you can get within your pricerange from a good brand.

When it comes to viewing experience, size is a massively overwhelming factor imo. Really draws you in and makes it more pleasurable rather than going 'oh yes, i had to settle for a 32" rather than 50"+ but the colours are so realistic! Honest!'.
Midda
Posts: 2356
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
^^What he said.

A quick Google (taken form the Panasonic website) puts a 50" 1366x768 plasma at $4,399 for RRP.
`ViPER`
Posts: 433
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
bah, RRP means nothing, the 1920x1080 panasonic plasma most places have sticker price of about $3300 and jb just had on special for just under 3k

http://www.theelectricdiscounter.com.au/asps/productpage1.asp?model=TH50PZ800A&extwarranty=4EWPPT4000

that one.

last edited by `ViPER` at 17:20:57 09/Jul/08
orbitor
Posts: 7647
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
don't forget this gem of a site:

http://hdtvprices.pbwiki.com/
`ViPER`
Posts: 434
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
thats sites awesome.
deadlyf
Posts: 107
Location: Queensland
Panasonic for plasma or Samsung for LCD, they are both good without being stupidly over priced like Pioneer/Sony. Go into a store and compare and choose which one looks best to you.

I've got the 50" Panasonic, it's pretty good but then I haven't run any consoles or a PC on it since I do that on my smaller LCD which is also pretty good. As far as I know the real difference is that you can replace the backlight in a LCD if it dies or gets dull but plasmas become landfill after a few years of use because the lights die or get too dim and can't be replaced. In other words if you go with plasma, get the extended warranty.

A quick Google (taken form the Panasonic website) puts a 50" 1366x768 plasma at $4,399 for RRP.

Mine is 1080p and cost me $3000 about 3 months ago from the Good Guys.


last edited by deadlyf at 17:30:05 09/Jul/08
Midda
Posts: 2357
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
but plasmas become landfill after a few years of use because the lights die or get too dim and can't be replaced.

I'm pretty sure it'd take like 10-15 years or so before that became an issue.
mission
Posts: 3837
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
I still say plasma, it just always looks better than lcd tome, sure lcd looks good for playing xbox/ps3 and cartoony movies, but on normal tv and movies, they just look pixelated.

Then again a super expensive Sony bravia LCD probably looks great for most things, but its just so much more than a similar size plasma.

52" sony bravias are over $5000 when you can get a 50" panasonic plasma for $3000, yes its 2 inches smaller, but 2 grand more, you could get another 42" plasma for that for the bedroom/other room, I know what i'd prefer.


This man speaks the truth.

I just did a bit of research and settled on a Panasonic Plasma. For the money you simply can't beat them. To get a comparable size LCD with comparable picture quality you'd pay at least $1,000 to $1,500 more.

LCD's really only start to get a good picture (ie: no or very little motion blur) at around the $3k mark. Beleive that it is obvious and the lizelating looks like balls. (Smaller LCD's may avoid this though).

Also really consider if the extra $'s are worth it for 'Full HD'. Don't just assume it is cause most people can't tell the differnce when viewing at a normal distance.

Best value on the market by far is the Panasonic Plasma 42". Can be had for $1,300. Bargain.


last edited by mission at 20:41:41 09/Jul/08
Tollaz0r!
Posts: 8828
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
We have a 42" plasma, 1080i, purchased it for $800 with 5 year warranty. Very happy with the size, it is a bit blurry at times. After watching it for a while you start to pick up on the bits that you pay an extra $500-1000 for. So when it dies I'll get a much better quality product and be able to appreciate the improvement.

Also, don't worry about paying extra for 1080p unless you plan on buying (or already have) a Bluray player and wanting to watch movies at 1080p.

last edited by Tollaz0r! at 22:54:42 09/Jul/08
Minxy
Posts: 515
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Samsung LCD's ftw
koopz
Posts: 7075
Location: New Zealand
I've been spending quite a bit of time of late checking out mate's plasma and lcd purchases to see what's what and how they look.

my biggest arguement against large (40+") lcds atm that it just doesn't suit the media I'd be pumping into it. most of the dvds/avis I play aren't high def (kids stuff, sci-fi collection, chick flicks for the Mrs), nor are most tv eps I have. most of my favourite old tv shows are never going to be re-leased in high-def.. this stuff looks like arse on my mate's 50" Samsung LCD (and my 22" at fullscreen for that matter). they look fine on my brother in-law's plasma.. I wasn't expecting the plasma to look good as I checked it out after the LCD and expected the same thing to happen again.

as for reading text - the lcd has it hands down for clarity. I just don't use the tv for cruising the net though. I lot of peeps would I suppose :/


I'm leaning towards a plasma atm.. what do you reckon of these Mongie?


last edited by koopz at 01:08:58 10/Jul/08
icewyrm
Posts: 1976
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
I'd go LCD. The anti burn in snow and fast screen dimming times on the plasma here at home annoy me. Well, assuming that LCDs aren't much more expensive for the same size.
Mass
Posts: 423
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
I've been doing heaps of research on this lately as I am getting ready to buy a 50" screen. After reading heaps of info and reviews from www.dtvforum.info and www.avsforum.com I am definitely buying a plasma.

I won't be gaming on the plasma and thats the only advantage the LCD has over plasma. I've looked at all the screens from a variety of sources and I don't think I could happily watch TV and movies on an LCD (yes even the Bravias). I currently have a HD SONY CRT, and I know I won't get as good a picture as that has on either Plasma or LCD, but the plasma is by and far the closest to it. I'll be running only the HTPC on the Plasma.
ravn0s
Posts: 6674
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
pretty much what ive read is plasma's are best for tv and movies. lcd's are best for gaming.
Spook
Posts: 22006
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
lcds are better for pcs also

which is what my tv is primarily used for (all medias off laptop)

dunno what koopz is smoking, but i can watch 720p media and it looks awesome, or just normal quality dvd rips and they look fine;

it actually looks just like a decent pc display, only its 50"
mongie
Posts: 5389
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
I'm leaning towards a plasma atm.. what do you reckon of these Mongie?


Good for the price Koopz, but I think its probably previous gen.

Current panasonic FullHD 50" is 30000:1 contrast + 134 billion colours and around 1300nits of brightness.


Could someone please explain to me what makes LCD's better for gaming? or for connecting a pc? (serious question)

last edited by mongie at 08:34:44 10/Jul/08
Raven
Posts: 2814
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
Okay, we have a problem (oh I love how spending lots of money on wants is a problem :p).

Oh, believe me it is. At the moment there's three expensive items I want (Dell 27", $799; Thylacine 221 frame, $2200; Canon EOS 450D+cards, $1200), and though I can easily afford all, I only want to spend the money on one of them.

Personally if it were me, with the Plasma vs LCD decision to make, I'd buy a decent LCD.

Current panasonic FullHD 50" is 30000:1 contrast + 134 billion colours and around 1300nits of brightness.

I was just thinking, you know how there's those people who think they're audiophiles and think they can tell the difference between things like 44kHz and 48kHz, and have to buy $500 cables, I bet you that somewhere out there there's the same kind of d******* for video who thinks they can tell the difference between 30000:1 and 30001:1.

last edited by Raven at 08:36:41 10/Jul/08
Kat
Posts: 9952
Location:
Well elvis is one of those weirdoes who can tell the difference. Our mythtv is connected by pbrycr something or other, because it looks better. I can't tell the difference between that and s-video or avi but I am weird.
He won't go to the extent to get $300 cables but he will make sure it is all set up so it looks proper. I just want to watch tv and play wii damnit!
Spook
Posts: 22008
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Could someone please explain to me what makes LCD's better for gaming? or for connecting a pc? (serious question)


no burn in for starters (yes, i know newer plasmas have protection, you still hear of people having problems with burnt in images on newer plasmas)

when i was looking for my tele, i checked plasmas with a laptop in the store, i didnt like the image as much as lcd:

didnt hurt that lcds were all higher res's at that stage either:

its just a crisper image from my pc on an lcd (at its native resolution)

last edited by Spook at 08:51:40 10/Jul/08
Mass
Posts: 424
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
If you treat a plasma like any new CRT it will be fine. There will be some image retention in the first 100-200hrs but will disappear after that time.

Everything I've read says that the phosphor trails when playing games on Plasmas are very distracting. You can play but its a bit annoying. I am leaning towards the 50" Full HD Panasonic, they are due in late July but I will probably wait another month or two and hopefully snap one up for around $2400.
Kat
Posts: 9953
Location:
I was looking at Samsungs and the 70" is $49k OMG
That's just under $700 per inch and a massive jump from 50"
Anono
Posts: 702
Location:
new plasmas dont have burn in problems, they have some image RETENTION to start with like said above, but not burn in.

1080p plasma are the same for pcs as lcds so spook is talking about old tech.

gaming has never been an issue with ps3, xbox360 or a minor bit on COD4 on my folks 50" last gen plasma so the new ones with better performance will be even better. got a 800 series panasonic plasma .
Spook
Posts: 22009
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
i think when major companies are abandoning plasma manufacturing , you have to ask yourself, "why?"
mongie
Posts: 5390
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Only one... Pioneer. Mainly because they're a low volume manufacturer.

They'll still be selling them too... Just Panasonic panels.
Raven
Posts: 2817
Location: Melbourne, Victoria
That's just under $700 per inch and a massive jump from 50"

The question is, is $700 per extra inch worth it?
mongie
Posts: 5391
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
I've never had any complaints (or noticed anything wrong) with my plasma when connected to my 360?

They do have some minor image retention, mainly if I'm playing a game with a "hud" that doesn't move and isn't translucent. After maybe 30 minutes, it might leave a feint shadow on screen and once the "hud" is no longer displayed, it takes about 5-10 seconds before the shadow is gone.

I can live with that for better colour reproduction and black levels.
ara
Posts: 2196
Location: Sydney, New South Wales

heh, just wait till you have a collection of burnt in channel watermarks and logos.

that will look real nice.
Spook
Posts: 22010
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
yer, after hours of gaming with my wii and using my pc nonstop on my tele, i have no noticeable marks on the screen

in fact it still looks as awesome as the day i bought it
mission
Posts: 3840
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
i think when major companies are abandoning plasma manufacturing , you have to ask yourself, "why?"


Probably the same reasons that Beta was canned and endless other products.

It's what the marketing people can convince the consumers is better that will win out, but that doesn't mean it is better.
Spook
Posts: 22013
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
if only there were more consumers with your super eye for detail mission, perhaps plasma would have won out

unfortunately (for plasma) most of us have lazy eyes that cant detect motion blur like you can
Anono
Posts: 704
Location:
spook seriously in what reality do you live? LCD has in no way "won out" or even come close to winning out.

Plasma is more appealing IQ wise then LCD at $ for $, " for " comparisons. Get a 50" plasma (pz800) from panasonic and you will be happy. Get a 46" LCD from samsung (series 6) you will also be happy. it will just be smaller but if you dont see them next to each other who cares. both are $2898 on wiki page.
sLiNky
Posts: 924
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
www.kogan.com.au
Spook
Posts: 22017
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
haha, i remember the kogan thread on whirlpool

that was some fun reading!

also, lolz anono
trog
AGN Admin
Posts: 24406
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
haha I want that kogan TV stand:

http://trog.qgl.org/up/kogan-tv-stand.jpg
Midda
Posts: 2367
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Trog posted nipples! Ban!
Anono
Posts: 708
Location:
http://www.cnet.com.au/tvs/0,239035250,240036500,00.htm
Obes
Posts: 6311
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Anono not only are you a noob for not being able to link s***... but its a s*** article...

They are trying to say a good street price for 42" standard def plasma for 2grand.

and "many TVs still have analogue tuners" ... not that I saw (other then the cheapest of the chinese spec stuff).
re so
I can't read
Posts: 4431
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
My Panasonic plasma still has an analogue tuner, it's just really really well hidden. I've never used it though - flicked to it once by accident and it looked so bad.
Midda
Posts: 2372
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
^^ Same. My LCD has an analogue tuner, but it also has a HD digital tuner. I had the TV for months before accidentally stumbling upon the hideousness that is analogue television.
orbitor
Posts: 7649
Location: Brisbane, Queensland


me2, and oh yeah it's a Full HD 50" Plasma :D
Spook
Posts: 22023
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
even my s***ty cheap lcd has an analogue tuner, dont use it though
koopz
Posts: 7078
Location: New Zealand
even my s***ty cheap lcd has an analogue tuner


is it a Kogan? :P


I'm tempted to buy one of their $1k 32" hd models for my gaming rig atm... dunno if I can handle waiting for upto 2 months for it to turn up though :(
ctd
Posts: 6263
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
I support lcd because I have numerous LCD panels. Could we get a team banner going>?
Spook
Posts: 22032
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
nah, my cheap lcd is a tevion (32") from aldi

it really does have a problem showing up blacks (unlike the sony in the living room)

but has no problems with motion blur (mission, you can ask your mum about it, she will tell you), and i only ever watch it in bed, which is straight on, so i woudlnt know if it has issues from side angles
casa
Thimes
Posts: 2956
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

I love these threads, it brings out the wanker in everyone.
uma
Posts: 1
Location: Other International

* N U K E D *

Reason: Inappropriate
Click Here to See the Profile for uma Edit This Post Click Here to send uma an email Users HomePage Message User
Obes
Posts: 6314
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Morons ... the implication in the thread was that the ONLY tuner the TV has was analogue and that you'd have to buy a set top box.
mission
Posts: 3842
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
mission, you can ask your mum about it, she will tell you


How was she? She does love a younger married man.

If you're so insistant on lack of motion blur in current lcd's maybe I'm referring to what I think looks like balls is. A very shmmering pixelation - especially on people faces is when it's most noticable.

When we recently went to look at some Tele's my wife, who knows nothing about them at all and has zero preferences on brands, technology etc etc, walked around the store and said (they were all playing the same thing, no....no.....no, and they were all LCD's (including 40" Sony at around $2,300) and one LG plasma. In fact one that had an awesome picture was a Fugitsu SD (yes SD) Plasma - must have found it in the back of the warehouse.

The one's she liked the picture of was 46" Bravia and Samsung (yes I know they are LCD but $3,000+ worth) and the Panasonic Plasma's, 42" and 50". ($1,500 and $2,200).

So that's a completely unbiased opinion from an average user who doesn't give a toss about specifications on a piece of paper, just evaluating a product on its intended use.

So in summary if your budget is under $3,000rrp plasma is by far the best option, over $3,000 a top shelf LCD should fit the bill.


mongie
Posts: 5397
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
I don't budget on RRP.
Fn
Posts: 5162
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
After a fair bit of research got the Plasma Panasonic full HD 50".
Fantastic everything I've found in either 360, movies or TV format.
Kat
Posts: 11203
Location:

Well we finally got around to buying.

Went to JB, the guy was a tad cocky and gave us a decent enough price. Went to HN and they matched the price plus gave us a better warranty. I don't normally haggle or do the walk around but I am glad we did :D Sony 1080 24p LCD 100hz, with a 4 year warranty.


last edited by Kat at 12:50:13 21/Sep/09
RockitMan
Posts: 5247
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
I prefer plasma for sure. LCD's just look weird to me. I don't know how to explain it but the movement and colouring, and everything => bizzare.
Opec
Posts: 5871
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
What size Kat?
Kat
Posts: 11204
Location:

We were going for a 42inch but alas, Sony didn't come in 42, so we had to get a 46" :P (and 32" for the bedroom)
mission
Posts: 5653
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
We now have a Plasma and LCD, LCD wins overall.

But if you're on a budget I still stand by my above comments that plasma is better value for money, especially sub $2k.
Opec
Posts: 5872
Location: Brisbane, Queensland

We were going for a 42inch but alas, Sony didn't come in 42, so we had to get a 46" :P (and 32" for the bedroom)


haha awesome "had" to get :) congrats, I love new TV day!
Spook
Posts: 26270
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
f*** yer, new tv day is aweosme (unless you get a plasma and then it ends up being a sad day)
Kat
Posts: 11205
Location:
http://i327.photobucket.com/albums/k479/ontheinternet/7391/100_0614.jpg

We only got it for the kids - I mean, what kind of parents would we be if we didn't give our kids a big box to play with
Spook
Posts: 26271
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
need more pix of your renos kat

whats left to do?
Kat
Posts: 11206
Location:
New decking is being laid as we speak.
Still have the kitchen to be done and the new windows and doors put in.
Then the house is getting painted.

It's looking awesome!!!! Not to mention the colours are now 100% better :D
Spook
Posts: 26272
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
how awesome are renos?!

we got a new fence going in today, i scored an extra 8 square meters of yard cleaning out all the junk between our place and next door (and filled skip no 7)

we're still waiting on our french doors to go in from the living room to deck and our bedroom to the deck, and a few little bits and pieces, and then i can start on the yard!



paveway
Posts: 10473
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
yeah been thinking about a 32" lcd for months and months now

i'd like a sony v series 32" they are kinda expensive though

LG seem so cheap <$1000

is that anything that bad about LG ?
Kat
Posts: 11207
Location:
i'd like a sony v series 32" they are kinda expensive though

JB have the W series for under $1k
paveway
Posts: 10475
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
i'm pretty sure the V series is as high as they go in the 32", i've been looking at them on an off for like 6 months. $1200~ i saw it for at JB on thursday night less 10% for their sale, which i think is over now

missus just bought a 40" V series from JB because her 46" W is a too big for the main room she'll use to watch tv in her new place
Splash
Posts: 2612
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
pave the sony shop at the DFO had a full hd 32" LCD for less than $1000 when I was there on the weekend, not sure on the model though
paveway
Posts: 10476
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
oh s*** i'll have to check that out

thanks bra

V series is full HD, i don't think there is a lower one with full HD in the 32"

last edited by paveway at 14:44:42 21/Sep/09
Kat
Posts: 11208
Location:
The 32inch we got is the W series. Exact same specs as the 46" 1080 24p 100hz
Kat
Posts: 11209
Location:
http://www.sony.com.au/product/kdl-32w5500
taggs
Posts: 3032
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
hn extended warranties aren't worth they paper they're printed on. the jb ones are marginally better, but still not worth the money.

XaltD
Posts: 540
Location: Queensland
Samsung LED
cJay
Posts: 1078
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
hn extended warranties aren't worth they paper they're printed on. the jb ones are marginally better, but still not worth the money


Never had a problem with HN extended warranties apart from the the slow ass process although thats kinda expected when returning goods 3 years later as apposed to a few months.
taggs
Posts: 3034
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
that's just super, you've had good luck.

i work for an insurance company (in retail warranties + motor insurance) which does the majority of extended warranties across the country, you wouldn't believe some of the s*** i've seen.
XaltD
Posts: 542
Location: Queensland
Extended warranties are only worth what the are printed on if you have something go wrong with your item, usually its dead out of the box or just at the 13th month part... all those "3 year warranty" rubbish is a waste of time - its just a manufacturers warranty, get a proper warranty with a no lemon guarantee and a fair wear and tear guarantee. Then its worth every cent, if your tv dies in 4.5 years out of a 5 year contract and you get a new TV - i am pretty sure the TV you are getting to replace it is awesome in comparison to the old p.o.s you just had die on you. Get it.

taggs
Posts: 3035
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
get a proper warranty with a no lemon guarantee and a fair wear and tear guarantee.


bwahahahaha. they all say that. read the T&C as to what actually has to happen before you can claim under the no-lemon clause.
koopz
Posts: 8020
Location: New Zealand
get a proper warranty with a no lemon guarantee and a fair wear and tear guarantee.


I've painfully learnt that the majority big name panels in the greater Brisbane area goto the same place in Coorparoo for repair regardless of the brand.

the staff in said repair centre are overworked and given my experiences with crews like this they're prolly also underpaid.

after 3 months the boss gave up on expecting our Panasonic 40" to ever be picked up as promised bi weekly. he replaced it with a cheapy that looks pretty much the same given the content that's run on it.

it needed a ~$150 psu replacement. if it was up to me I would have just taken it down the Compy Alliance and paid Dave M to do it for me in a few weeks

PSU failure is the most common cause of panel failure (next to dead pixels in LCDs).

hope this helps ya peeps

last edited by koopz at 21:37:08 21/Sep/09
XaltD
Posts: 543
Location: Queensland
I meant the extended warranty. I'm in management in retail and from my experiences the extended warranty we sell is actually quite good and i see MANY items just swapped over for new ones. Happens all the time. Manufacturers warranty isn't really worth much.
taggs
Posts: 3040
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
koopz is talking about the extended warranty! and koopz' experience is pretty goddamn typical. most warranty providers have only a handful (or one) repairer for a particular brand/appliance in a city. so the wait times are rediculous and the repairs often less than satisfactory. if you get lucky and get it replaced.. good for you, but it doesn't happen anywhere near as often as you're making it out to happen. you wanna know how i know? because regularly work in the department that authorises the f***ing things.

and i'm sure you know a whole lot about it... more than someone who works for one of the largest warranty providers in aus and deals with them every day (me).

what extended warranties do you sell? because there are only a few seperate providers in aus. hn group, good guys have their own things and then theres the other one which does pretty much everyone else iirc.

edit: and i am also talking about the extended warranty. seriously, read the T&C as to what has to happen before you can claim under the no-lemon clause...

and how can you say a manufacturer's warranty is useless and an ext warranty isn't... an extended warranty MIRRORS the T&C of the man warranty, except they throw extra exlusions in there. so it's actually less useful. you sound like every goddamn retailer who sells our s***... you don't have a clue what you're selling (which is good otherwise noone would buy them).

edited my post to make where i work slightly less obvious, in case the powers that be troll qgl!

last edited by taggs at 08:14:55 22/Sep/09
fpot
Posts: 16409
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland
f*** can you stop ranting and tell us some of these things that need to happen in the no-lemon clause already! :P
RockitMan
Posts: 5250
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
HN has database warranty system so you don't need your receipt - it's all on their system under your name. I like that.
paveway
Posts: 10479
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
yeah pretty over hearing about warranties

you must be a pretty interesting guy, interesing like an accountant :p
infi
Posts: 13568
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
extended warranties are a reinsurance product by a third party afaik. if a long warranty is important to you, then research the actual models and buy one with an adequate manufacturer warranty.

my mate who works for an electrical seller said for example the new model samsungs are coming out with a 1 year warranty, whereas my older model had a three year.

why the f*** would a manufacturer wind their warranty back? it shows they believe in their product.

last edited by infi at 09:18:54 22/Sep/09
mission
Posts: 5660
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
My Samsung has 2 (pretty sure).

Next they'll have no warranty 3-2-1....0
mongie
Posts: 6675
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Most have a 1 year warranty now...

Officeworks extended warranties used to be great for both the consumer and the retailer.

It was a replacement warranty... underwritten by AIG.
Mass
Posts: 653
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Pioneer TVs had the best warranty - 5yr manufacturer. Shame they are out of the market. The TV price used to include delivery and installation aswell.
mongie
Posts: 6676
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
They also used to cost nearly double what everything else costed.

(They were good though).
Crakaveli
Posts: 3636
Location: USA
looking at getting a 32" Sony V series aswell, best prices i've seen so far is $1200 from the good guys.. how the hell do you haggle with them and then go somewhere else to get a price match/reduction? a written quote?

I'm a noob to this haggling s*** (gonna pay cash).
skythra
Posts: 1394
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Well my experience with the good guys was quite literally walking into HN's and getting someone's card, i then wrote on the back of the card a price and model number. Walked into Good Guys and said "this is what harvey normans can do, can you beat it?" when they were like oh i'm not sure i replied "the guy was nice so i'll call him because you know he served me first thanks for your time" they walked to their boss after asking me to wait, and i got it slightly better than the price i wrote down.
taggs
Posts: 3041
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
mongie, not done by AIG any more. we do it :(

rofl, my job makes accountancy look crazy exciting :(++

rofl x2, if you really wanna know fpot pm me. i don't wanna post any more incriminating s*** just in case someone from work reads auslamers, people get fired for posting (admittedly stupid) s*** on facebook about work at my company :(+++

but basically the requirements are so far fetched it simply never happens. i've seen claims paid out i think only a handful of times (5 or less) under that clause in over 2 years.
Crakaveli
Posts: 3637
Location: USA
Interesting, JB-Hifi has the 32" Sony V series listed for $995.00 and at the good guys it's $1200. Worth getting a quote then taking it to the good guys and get the price beaten or just get it for 995? Was orignally hoping to only spend $1000 anyway.
paveway
Posts: 10490
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
what the f*** $995

i was there on thursday last week and it was $1200 odd

Crakaveli
Posts: 3638
Location: USA
Linky
Spook
Posts: 26285
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
goodguys are s***
reload!
Posts: 4783
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
LSD
fpot
Posts: 16429
Location: Gold Coast, Queensland
Mongie it was 5 pages ago but couldn't you see the obvious bias in that article you posted?
Kat
Posts: 11210
Location:
W > V
mission
Posts: 5673
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
DD > B
paveway
Posts: 10491
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
kat i don't think you got a W for less than $1000 if that's what they are selling the V for..
Kat
Posts: 11211
Location:
When we were at JB, he said the Sony 32inch was 985 in reply to Good Guys having them at 995. He said it was the exact same as the 46inch (and that was the W)

No, we didn't get ours for under $1k, because we got an extended warranty We did not pay this price before the warrenty was tacked on
http://www.jbhifionline.com.au/plasma-lcd-tvs/lcd-tv/sony-kdl32w5500-32-inch-w5500-series-full-hd-bravia-lcd-tv/436709
Crakaveli
Posts: 3639
Location: USA
Yeah $1400 is a bit out of my range unfortunately.
paveway
Posts: 10505
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
and i still think you have a V series kat
tequila
Posts: 3310
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
taggs i want to know more about fpot
he's so dreamy

Crakaveli
Posts: 3641
Location: USA
i can tell you about paveway.
mission
Posts: 5680
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
i can tell you about paveway's mum.
Kat
Posts: 11215
Location:

and i still think you have a V series kat

We have the W series. It's kinda hard not to know with the box, model numbers and features
paveway
Posts: 10537
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
ended up buying a series 5 samsung 32" today, good guys carseldine had a good price on it and i got a hdmi cable for like half price with it

it's a slightly better TV than the V series i was looking at anyway

got it for $1070 fyi, i got the second last one
Spook
Posts: 26354
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
samsung teles are awesome

ive been pimping the samsungs as much as the sony teles
paveway
Posts: 10538
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
we know good tv's dave
Midda
Posts: 4103
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
Yeah, Samsung make awesome TVs. In fact, don't Samsung and Sony use the same panels? I'm sure they used to, at least.
Spook
Posts: 26356
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
dan, i just happy u didnt have to settle
mission
Posts: 5699
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
We have a 32" Samsung series 5, great tele.

Except its channel changing and FTA guide populating can be slow :( (compared to Panasonic), about my only complaint.

last edited by mission at 20:45:30 27/Sep/09
HeardY
Gaelic newb
Posts: 16490
Location: Sydney, New South Wales
http://www.smh.com.au/digital-life/hometech/the-year-the-plasma-died-20090930-gc35.html
paveway
Posts: 10577
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
mongie wails in dispair
Spook
Posts: 26403
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
fyi, plasma has been dead to me for years
HeardY
Gaelic newb
Posts: 16491
Location: Sydney, New South Wales
In other news I was talking to a mate who I haven't seen since I was in Ireland last night and he is a plasma fanboi as well, saying LCD's are s*** for sport (particularly league) I lol'd. Told him to watch footy on a decent LCD not no name s*** and it'll be fine
mongie
Posts: 6689
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
The year the plasma died?


(My emphasis)

Samsung, one of the three largest television manufacturers still making plasma TVs, said that, although demand was flattening, it had retained a big stake in the technology since launching the world's thinnest plasma display (2.5 centimetres), and integrating wireless technologies and internet television into recent models.

“Plasma accounts for 25-30 per cent of the market, which means there is still a very large market there,” said Evan Manolis, a senior product manager for Samsung's audio-visual unit in Australia.

“There are still a lot of people that really love the look of plasma, the softness of the screen, the [rich] blacks and the capacity to handle motion. So the big challenge for plasma is the drive towards energy consumption as consumers become more aware of the environment. We have reduced plasma energy consumption by 40 per cent compared with 2007 models,” he said.



<3 Mongie.



mongie
Posts: 6690
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
I will also mention... Its not the first time that a superior technology has been beaten for market share...

Betamax anyone?
Saint
Cainer
Posts: 2441
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
I will also mention... Its not the first time that a superior technology has been beaten for market share...

But LCD hasn't been beaten?
paveway
Posts: 10580
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
lolz saint hi5
Opec
Posts: 5893
Location: Brisbane, Queensland
I love my Plasma. Can't beat the price/performance to size ratio of Plasma (at the moment). Until they start making affordable 50+ inch LCD screens, I'd still be buying Plasma :)
system
--
Not a new post since your last visit.
New Post Since your last visit
Back To Forum
Advertise with Us | Privacy Policy | Contact Us
© Copyright 2001-2026 AusGamers Pty Ltd. ACN 093 772 242.
Hosted by Mammoth Networks - Australian VPS Hosting
Web development by Mammoth Media.